Replace or reface: the question to settle first
Every cabinet project begins with one decision that changes the rest of the plan. Either the existing boxes come out and new ones go in, or the boxes stay and their faces are renewed with new doors, drawer fronts and a fresh surface on the visible frames. Neither path is automatically smarter. The right answer depends on what the boxes look like today, how well the layout works, and what you want the finished kitchen to do.
Refacing makes sense when the boxes are sound, square and laid out the way you actually cook. The footprint stays, the countertop often stays, and the plumbing and electrical stay where they are. What changes is the look of the doors and the feel of the hardware. Replacement makes sense when the layout is the problem, when boxes are swollen or soft, or when you want different depths, taller uppers or a new run of drawers.
A walkthrough settles this more clearly than any catalog can. When we look at a kitchen we open every door, check the bases for movement, look under the sink for past moisture, and ask what bothers you most. If you want a deeper side by side look first, the comparison page on refacing versus replacing cabinets lays out the trade offs in plain terms.
- Choose refacing when the boxes are sturdy and the layout already works for you.
- Choose replacement when the layout, depth or storage needs to change.
- Choose replacement when boxes show swelling, soft spots or old moisture damage.
- Ask for both options written into the scope so you can compare them honestly.
What the cabinet box is made of and why it matters
From the front, two kitchens can look alike while the boxes behind the doors are very different. The box is the carcass: sides, bottom, top rails, back and shelves. Common materials include plywood, particleboard and fiberboard with a surface layer, and each behaves differently when it meets moisture, weight and time. Plywood generally handles water exposure and screw holding better, while composite panels can be perfectly sound in dry areas and fail where water sits.
The sink base is where this shows up first. A cabinet under a sink lives next to supply lines, a drain and a dishwasher connection, so it sees more leaks and condensation than any other box in the room. If the existing sink base has swollen edges or a soft floor, that is a sign worth telling your contractor about even if the rest of the kitchen looks fine. It affects whether refacing is realistic.
Back panels, shelf thickness and drawer boxes also matter day to day. Drawers that carry pots and plates need sturdy sides and solid slides. When you compare quotes, ask what the box and drawer construction actually is, not just the door style, because that is where two similar looking proposals can differ the most.
Framed and frameless construction
Cabinets come in two broad construction styles. Framed boxes have a solid face frame around the opening, and doors sit either on top of the frame or inside it. Frameless boxes, often called full access, have no face frame, so the door covers the whole box and the opening is a little wider. The two styles also look different: framed cabinets show a visible border, frameless ones look flatter and cleaner.
Frameless boxes give slightly more usable interior room, which helps with pot drawers and corner solutions. Framed boxes tend to feel traditional and can be more forgiving in older homes where walls and floors are not perfectly flat, since the frame helps hold the box square. This is a design and fit question, not a quality ranking, and the details are covered in the page on framed versus frameless cabinets.
If your home is an older South Florida house with walls that have settled over time, say so during the walkthrough. Out of plumb walls and floors that slope toward a drain change how the boxes are shimmed and set, and that planning belongs in the written scope rather than being discovered on install day.
Door styles and how they change the room
Door style does more to set the character of a kitchen than almost any other choice. Flat slab doors read as modern and quiet. Shaker style doors, with a simple recessed center panel, sit comfortably in almost any home and are easy to wipe clean. Raised panel doors with more profile feel traditional, and they collect a bit more dust in their grooves. Glass fronted uppers can lighten a wall, but they ask you to keep the inside tidy.
Finish matters as much as style. Painted doors give clean color and a smooth look, but they show chips at edges over time. Wood stained doors show grain and age gracefully. Laminate and thermally fused surfaces are durable and consistent. In a humid climate, the finish and the edge sealing are what keep doors flat, so ask how edges are sealed and how the finish is meant to be cleaned.
Consider the doors with the rest of the kitchen, not alone. A bold door color next to a busy countertop pattern can compete, and a very pale door next to a pale backsplash can feel flat. Samples held up in your own light, morning and evening, tell you much more than a small chip under store lighting. Our guide to choosing kitchen cabinets goes through these choices step by step.
Hardware, hinges and the things you touch every day
Hardware is the part of a cabinet you handle dozens of times a day, so it deserves a decision rather than an afterthought. Pulls and knobs are the visible part. Hinges and drawer slides are the hidden part, and they decide whether a door closes softly and a drawer glides or catches. Soft close hinges and full extension drawer slides are common options worth pricing into the scope so they are not a surprise later.
Placement of pulls is a design detail with practical consequences. Pulls too close to a corner can bump a hip, pulls set too high on a lower drawer can feel awkward, and long pulls on narrow doors can look out of scale. A good habit is to tape a paper template of the pull to a door or drawer and live with it for a day before the order is placed.
Finish of hardware should suit the salt air and humidity of a coastal region. Some plated finishes tarnish or pit near the ocean, while others hold up well. Ask what the hardware is made of and how it is finished, especially if your home is close to the water. Interior accessories such as pull out trays, trash pull outs and spice drawers work better when chosen at the same time as the boxes.
- Decide hinge and slide type before the cabinet order is placed.
- Mock up pull size and position with paper templates on your own doors.
- Ask how hardware finishes behave near salt air and constant humidity.
- Choose interior accessories at the same time as the boxes, not after.
Layout changes that new cabinets make possible
Replacing cabinets is the moment to ask whether the layout is serving you. A new run of drawers in place of a door base, a taller upper to the ceiling, a slim pantry cabinet beside the refrigerator, or a corner solution that actually reaches the back can change daily life far more than a new door color. The cost of the idea is mostly in coordination, because moving a box can mean moving a plumbing line, a gas line or a receptacle.
Anything that shifts the sink, the range or the dishwasher pulls other trades into the plan. In our process, core trades are in house, and specialist work such as some electrical or mechanical work is done by a specialist trade under our coordination. That coordination is what keeps cabinet changes from turning into rework later. Our kitchen layout basics guide is a good place to think through work zones before you talk about moving anything.
If a wall is part of the layout idea, that is a separate planning question about structure, ducts and wiring, covered on the open concept kitchen conversions page. For a kitchen that keeps its footprint, new cabinets can still add storage through better depth use, deeper drawers and smarter dividers.
Humidity, salt air and what cabinets have to survive
South Florida kitchens work in a climate that is hard on wood products. Humidity rises and falls, air conditioning cycles on and off, and coastal homes carry salt in the air. Cabinet boxes and doors swell when they take up moisture, then shrink again, and over many cycles that movement shows up as gaps, warped doors and peeling finish. Good materials and well sealed edges slow that down, but they do not stop physics.
Ventilation matters more than most people expect. A range hood that actually moves cooking steam and grease outdoors protects the cabinets above and beside the stove. A dishwasher with a proper steam barrier or a cabinet liner next to it helps too. These are details to raise with your contractor and with the person supplying the cabinets, because they are easy to include at install time and hard to add afterward.
If you are trying to understand how climate affects a whole project, the guide on humidity and your renovation covers it, and the page on sagging or damaged cabinets explains what to watch for in boxes you already own, including what signs suggest the boxes are past saving.
Ordering, lead times and your schedule
Cabinets are rarely sitting on a shelf. Most are built or finished to order, and the time between a confirmed order and delivery is the part of a kitchen schedule that nobody controls fully. It depends on the line you choose, whether a finish is custom, and how busy the supplier is. We do not promise a number for it, and you should be wary of anyone who does before the order is confirmed in writing.
The smart move is to ask the question early: what is the lead time on this line, and what happens to the schedule if it changes? Final measurements usually come after demolition or at least after a careful field check, so the order often waits for them. That means the order, the deliveries and the install need to be sequenced in the plan from the first day, not guessed at.
While you wait, other work can often proceed, such as electrical rough work, drywall repair and painting prep, depending on what your scope includes. Our guide to lead times and ordering walks through how to ask for an honest sequence and what to do if a delivery slips.
Demolition, installation and what happens around the cabinets
When old cabinets come out, the room reveals itself. Walls may need patching, flooring may stop short of where new boxes will sit, and plumbing or electrical may need adjustment. This is the point where our rule applies: anything found behind a wall pauses the work and comes to you as a written change order with a price before it proceeds. You always know what you are agreeing to.
Installation is more than hanging boxes. Uppers are set to a level line, bases are shimmed to the floor, fillers close odd gaps, and everything is scribed to the wall so edges look intentional. Crown, toe kick and trim pieces finish the look. Countertops follow, because the templating depends on the cabinets being in place and fixed. See the kitchen countertop installation page to understand why those steps run in that order.
At the end of every working day we clean the site, which matters in a kitchen you may still be living near. If you are staying at home during the work, the page on setting up a temporary kitchen will help you plan meals while the cabinets are out.
Scope, allowances and a fixed price
Every project starts with a walkthrough and a written scope that spells out what is included and what is not. For cabinets, the scope should name the line, the door style, the finish, the hardware, the interior accessories and who orders what. A fixed price is then set against that written scope before work begins. If something is still undecided, it should appear as an allowance with a clear description, not a vague line.
An allowance is a placeholder for a choice not yet made, such as hardware or specialty accessories. If your final selection costs more than the allowance, the difference is yours, and if it costs less the difference comes back. Read allowance lines carefully when you compare estimates, because a low looking proposal sometimes carries unrealistic allowances. The guide on allowances explained shows how to read them.
Work around the cabinets also needs to be named: removal and disposal of old boxes, repairs to walls and floors behind them, and any plumbing or electrical adjustments. This is how you keep the scope honest. For the whole picture of a kitchen job, visit our kitchen remodeling page.
Finishing touches, adjustments and the punch list
Once cabinets are installed, small adjustments make the difference between good and great. Doors are aligned so reveals are even, drawers are tuned to open straight, soft close mechanisms are checked, and touch up is done on any nicks from installation. This work is easy to overlook and should be part of the scope, not left for you to chase down.
Before final payment, we walk the punch list with you together. You open each door, run each drawer and look at every seam. If something is not right, it goes on the list and is corrected. One point of contact from estimate to punch list means you always know who to call, and you never need to sort out which trade did what.
If you are ready to compare your kitchen against a checklist, the kitchen selections checklist is designed to be filled in before the cabinet order is placed, so decisions are made calmly and the order is correct the first time.
Common questions
Can I keep my existing countertop if I reface the cabinets?
Often yes, because refacing keeps the boxes in place and the footprint unchanged. The countertop has to be in good condition and the new doors and drawer fronts must clear its edge and overhang properly. It is worth confirming during the walkthrough, since a countertop that is damaged or loose may need attention anyway.
How do I know whether my cabinet boxes are worth keeping?
Open the doors and look at the bottoms, sides and especially the sink base for swelling, soft spots, stains or mold smell. Check whether boxes are level and whether the layout suits you. If the structure is sound and the layout works, reusing the boxes through refacing is a reasonable option to price.
Do cabinet orders affect the rest of the schedule?
Yes. Countertop templating, backsplash, final paint and final plumbing connections all depend on the cabinets being installed. Because delivery time varies by line and finish, we ask about it before you commit and sequence other work around it. We do not promise a number before the order is confirmed in writing.
Will you move plumbing or electrical when we change the layout?
Layout changes can involve moving a sink, range or receptacle. Our core trades are in house, and some electrical or mechanical work is done by a specialist trade under our coordination. Permits are pulled where the work requires them, and your city building department sets those requirements.
What if something is found behind the old cabinets?
Work pauses on the affected area, and the finding comes to you as a written change order with a price before anything proceeds. You decide with the facts in front of you. Common examples are old water damage, uneven walls or outdated wiring that needs adjusting to fit the new layout.
What should I decide before the cabinet order is placed?
Settle the door style, finish, box construction, hardware, interior accessories, appliance sizes and any layout changes. Confirm measurements against the actual room, and make sure the written scope names each item. Changes after an order is placed can be difficult or impossible, so the checklist on our planning pages is a good tool.



